• barsoap@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    edit-2
    27 days ago

    When protestants started the logical stance that the bread and wine is a metaphor being used in the Eucharist,

    That’s never been the Lutheran position, at least for all I know. The Lutheran position is “whatever happens, happens, regardless of what you think it is that happens”: If someone is saying “This is my flesh, this is my blood” while handing out suitable food and drink and the giver and the recipients are in the mood to receive the sacrament, then it is the sacrament, no matter what metaphysics anyone involved believes in.

    I cant see the stubbornness lapsing when it came to say women can suddenly perform magic

    Oh but there’s the priesthood of all believers, even the Catholics accept that as doctrine. It’s not about whether or not women, or laypeople, can or cannot perform the magic, it’s whether they should be doing it in the church, for a congregation. I’m pretty sure there’s women cloisters where women are doing the magic. The Lutheran church, too, restricts the incantation of the magic words to the reverend, but that’s a church rule. Like, “If it was on the schedule and the reverend is sick in bed the cantor isn’t going to jump in we’ll do it at another date”.

    • LifeInMultipleChoice@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      27 days ago

      Yeah, the Lutherans were the first split from Catholicism and sort of what I would say would be the start of protestantism. Not that Martin Luther initially wanted that, but he wanted a return to basics and a simpler less controlling version of what the church had slowly become. (95? Thesis and what not… maybe it was 99 can’t recall)

      Now we have thousands of denominations of Christians, and they all do their own versions of how they believe things should be. Haven’t studied the historys of religion in a long time, it’s crazy to think about how much I’m sure things have changed and I’ve distorted in my brain throughout time when I reflect on the fact that it has been more than 15 years since the last real class I would have taken. Getting older is strange.

      Some day it’d be nice to start studying history more again.